stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip

13 reviews for stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip

1. 

   Sidney Reed – 6 January 2025

   Humid, Sweat, Water, Allergy, Everything Proof! AT LAST!!!
   I’ve been wearing eyeliner since high school. I’m Japanese, and I love that cat-eye look. But two things drove me crazy: 1) I have a natural eye fold, but it’s not large enough to prevent creasing, and 2) most eyeliner has a bulky brush attached to the screw cap that is awful and clumpy.Enter…Stila Liquid Eyeliner. This baby is like a fine sumi ink brush. It goes on like rich, smooth, delicious Sharpie ink. The blacks are bold and intense. The brush doesn’t clog or clump or leave flecks of dried eyeliner in your eyes. You can draw a cat-eye. You can draw fake eyelashes. Heck, you can draw tiny designs in the corner of your eyes if you want! And it will stay there all day, in the rain and swimming pool and humidity and sweat, until you remove it with makeup cleanser. Or, if you’ve had a crazy day and crash on the sofa, you’ll wake up with flawless eyeliner (even if your foundation looks like crap).And it lasts, too! I wear a thick band of eyeliner on the tops and bottoms, plus a cat-eye wing, everyday and one stick lasts me a month or two. You can put it on the bottom eyeline as well. I would NOT recommend you line your waterline with it though. The black comes out liquidy (hence the beautiful thin lines), so if it touches your water line it will spread like watercolor paint. It won’t sting your eyes at all, but looks gross when the whites of your eyes flood grey. Just dab it out with a q-tip.Instead, keep your eyes very dry. Wipe with toner, then apply eye cream, foundation, and a matte powder. This creates the perfect, dry, smooth surface for your eyeliner. You will have wonderfully crisp, jet black lines. Easy to fill between your eyelashes and create designs. So lovely! If you have slightly oily skin, or leave it bare, this product will not look as nice. Drawing it on unprepped skin gives it a harsh, crude look. The edges of the lines might look jagged or crooked. At minimum, apply a tinted primer.I will buy this product forever. If the company threatens to go under, I’ll buy enough of their remaining stock to last until my senior citizen age. I cannot recommend this product enough! Remember, prep your eye area well!

2. 

   Bobby McWilliams – 6 January 2025

   Long Lasting
   I love this brown eyeliner! It’s waterproof and stays on all day without smudging or fading. I’ve worn it through long days and even some sweaty workouts, and it stays perfectly in place. The color is rich and blends smoothly, giving a natural look that is perfect for everyday wear. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that won’t smear and will last all day, this is the one to try!

3. 

   Brinni – 6 January 2025

   Ride or die liner
   Doesn’t last long in the tube with how much I wear it. But it’s waterproof, has strong color, soft brush and smooth glide. Easy application too.

4. 

   Eva Meg – 6 January 2025

   Good quality item
   This is my first time trying this specific brand and I’m happy so far. It really is waterproof. I did my make up in the morning before I went out to the hot garage to clean it out. My eye make up stayed in place despite the fact that I was sweating. I like the thin tip because it makes a really nice line and I don’t want it thin I can simply go back and make it thicker. It seems to have a lot of product inside. Happy with my purchase.

5. 

   Gabi Holland – 6 January 2025

   My go-to eyeliner!
   I bought this eyeliner for prime day, since I use it daily. It’s the perfect black color, and dries quickly without any smudging (as long as you don’t blink while it’s drying.) The tip is medium sized so it’s perfect for winged eyeliner, not too big, not too small. I wouldn’t use it for very intricate or thin lines, but it’s perfect for my everyday use. It’s waterproof and won’t come off if it gets wet, however, it might come off if you rub your eyes harshly. It comes off easily with any makeup remover, which is great. Overall, a great eyeliner and a great brand. I use it daily and would highly recommend for anyone in the market for a good black eyeliner.

6. 

   jerrilynn fagan – 6 January 2025

   PLEASE…NEVER DISCONTINUE!
   I absolutely love this product. I have ordered this product many times on Amazon and in stores. I have oily skin and makeup can come off easily. I use the dark brown for every day and it is a very nice chocolate brown. I use the black for nights out. This goes on very smoothly and stays on all day.

7. 

   Amyla – 6 January 2025

   You have to have a steady hand to apply
   This is a good product. This is not my favorite liquid eyeliner on the market though. However, when I try to wipe it off of my arm that I have an attached photo, It does not smudge. That is very good. But please keep in mind that you have to have a steady hand as this wand has a propensity to apply thick so if you’re just wanting a very thin line, you’re going to have to take some time and be very diligent that you’re only using the tip and that you don’t slide it too much to the side. So applying it is not going to be very easy. But on the flipside to that, if you are wanting a thicker line, you can have that and if you’re wanting a thinner line you can as well so does versatile in that way. You just have to be very intentional when applying.It is not a blendable eyeliner, It is not intended to be. It is not an eyeliner that will bleed, But you have to make sure it’s dry but it does dry fairly fast.Again, this is a good product. It is not my favorite for the price and lack of ease of application especially for those with time restrictions.

8. 

   Hallie Fitzsimons – 6 January 2025

   Best Eyeliner!
   I used Bare Minerals eyeliner for years and needed to find a new brand, love this one is Vegan and cruelty free that is a must, and it holds up with sweat, or oily skin. I am thrilled how well this eyeliner holds up and stays all day. My new favorite

9. 

   Amazon Customer – 6 January 2025

   Love the color and the brush, it’s lasting nicely without drying out. It’s not completely waterproof but stays on all day even with a bit of rain. Easy enough to remove with regular facial cleanser.

10. 

    Joyce Goodyear – 6 January 2025

    Excellent doesn’t transfer

11. 

    Audrey Rogers – 6 January 2025

    It keeps a perfect a perfect point and stays somewhat.

12. 

    Jules – 6 January 2025

    This is by far the best liquid eyeliner pen on the market, I have been using it for years with zero complaints. It goes on smooth, lasts all day, and washes off easily at night. It doesn’t smudge or run. I get compliments all the time on my wings.

13. 

    Ann L Potvin – 6 January 2025

    Great line. Great colour. But only lasts a minute. Hardly anything in the tube.